When I started investing, I didn’t have a clue. I’d never heard of words like tax-loss harvesting, rebalancing, or mutual funds. I thought it was completely reasonable to pay my financial advisor a 1% annual fee. Someone had to rebalance my portfolio, right?
And brokerage firms? I couldn’t have told you who Vanguard was let alone John C. Bogle.
But then I got curious. I started reading about personal finance. Now I’m startled by some of the words escaping my lips:
Who had I become? Life is an evolution. Enjoy the change.
Speaking of Betterment vs Vanguard, I’m going to show you who they are, why they’re great, and which is the better choice for you.
An Executive Summary
Invest free for up to 1 year
Tax Loss Harvesting:
Assets Under Management:
0.04% - 0.30% advisory fee
Tax Loss Harvesting:
Assets Under Management:
Vanguard was founded in 1975 by John Bogle. Mr. Bogle championed low-cost, buy-and-hold investing, scoffed at Wall Street, and fought tooth and nail to lower costs for ordinary investors.
Instead of having investors try to pick winning stocks, he thought it would be more advantageous if investors owned every stock in the index and mirrored the returns of the market.
Mr. Bogle saw the correlation between low management fees and exceptional investment returns with a buy-and-hold-own-every-stock-in-the-index approach.
Andrew wrote a detailed article on why mirroring an index for an “average market return” is superior to market timing or picking individual stocks.
Vanguard is also client-owned. You, a shareholder of Vanguard funds, own a piece of the company (spoiler alert: it’s how they can keep costs so low).
Holding a contrarian position to how other mutual fund companies operate, Vanguard operates at cost: you only pay for the costs to manage the fund – nothing else. As Mr. Bogle said in this article from Market Watch:
This business is all about simplicity and low cost. I’m not into all these market strategies and theories and cost-benefit analyses – all the bureaucracy that goes with business. In investing, strip all the baloney out of it, and give people what you promise.
Vanguard has grown to $5.3 trillion in assets under management (AUM), is the largest provider of mutual funds, and the second-largest provider of ETFs in the world.
Betterment CEO John Stein also sought to make investing more accessible by lowering costs and minimum balance requirements while embracing the buy-and-hold approach espoused by John Bogle.
Founded in 2008, Betterment now has over $18 billion AUM.
Their mission statement:
We’re building smarter, more efficient money management for everyone… By pushing the bounds of what technology can do, by bringing together the best software and analytic thinking of diverse, cutting-edge industries, we’re able to ensure that more get the advice that they deserve.
Stein took inspiration from John Bogle and the Vanguard group. The two met briefly in 2009, while Bogle was on campus to promote his book, Enough.
Jon feverishly pitched his ideas while Bogle listened attentively, asking questions, until finally saying to Stein, “You’re going to help a lot of people. Stay the course!”
Betterment’s service does what the competition tries to do at a fraction of the cost – with better results.
They’re an SEC-Registered Investment Advisor, an SEC-registered broker-dealer regulated by FINRA, and a member of SIPC (which means your money is insured up to $500,000).
They’re now one of the biggest robo-advisors in the country.
We even had Jon Stein on our podcast for a chat. Have a listen!
Get our best strategies, tools, and support sent straight to your inbox.
Whether you want to open a Betterment account or use Vanguard Personal Advisor Services, you’re gonna need some cash. How much exactly?
Vanguard is the low-cost leader. Their funds are 83% less expensive than the industry average.
Compare that to a 0.58% industry average.
Keeping up with Vanguard’s low prices have led to a phenomenon: the Vanguard Effect. Mutual fund companies are forced to offer similar-priced products to compete with their low costs.
Betterment is also a superior, low-cost alternative to other brokerage firms with an average ETF expense ratio varying between 0.07% and 0.15%.
It’s no secret Betterment uses Vanguard funds (along with Charles Schwab and iShares) in their investment portfolios and explains the low cost.
Vanguard has several investment options, each with its own account minimum. If you want to access their catalog of over 3,000 no-transaction-fee mutual funds, you’ll need at least $1,000.
Their Target Date Retirement Funds and Star Funds both have a $1,000 minimum, while their Admiral Shares cost $3,000. ETFs, stocks, CDs, and bonds all cost the price of one share.
If you’re looking for that personal touch only an advisor can give, you’ll need a $50,000 minimum to take advantage of the Vanguard Personal Advisor Service.
Betterment has no minimum, which makes them very attractive to investors with low account balances. If you’re getting started and prefer someone to manage your money for a small fee, Betterment might make sense.
Both Betterment and Vanguard offer its services for pennies on the dollar of what other financial advisors charge. We hate fees. Even a 1% fee (sounds small until you do the math) has a substantial impact on your portfolio’s long-term return.
Beware of little expenses. A small leak will sink a great ship. – Ben Franklin
Vanguard’s advisory service costs 0.30% on assets below $5 million (don’t forget about that $50,000 minimum too). Portfolios are constructed on a client-by-client basis, depending on your investment strategy.
***The above is an example of Vanguard’s advisory service portfolio playing out “what-if” scenarios***
However, the higher your account balance, the lower your fee. For example:
- Your fee drops to 0.20% on assets between $5-$10 million
- Assets between $10 million and $25 million carry a 0.10% management fee
- $25 million and above cost you 0.05%.
Betterment has two tiers: its Digital Plan and Premium Plan.
- The Digital Plan has an annual 0.25% management fee and has no account minimum
- Premium Plan carries a 0.40% fee and has a $100,000 minimum account balance requirement
You can stay with the Digital Plan forever, or when you hit $100,000, you can upgrade to Premium.
Betterment does offer a 0.10% discount on account balances above $2 million. For example, your Digital Plan would lower to 0.15% (normally 0.25%), and your Premium Plan will cost 0.30% (normally 0.40%)
Vanguard can supplement its management fee by using its own funds, which is an advantage Betterment doesn’t have (e.g., Betterment’s higher fee of 0.40%). For the services offered, Betterment’s Premium Plan is closer to what you’ll find with Vanguard’s Personal Advisory Service.
Financial Advice: Schedule A Call
Betterment offers clients access to several financial packages if you stay on their Digital Plan. You can schedule a call (45-60 minutes) with a certified financial planner for a one-time fee costing between $199 to $299. You can choose from:
- Getting Started Package ($199)
- Financial Checkup ($299)
- College Planning ($299)
- Marriage or Retirement Planning package ($299)
If you decide to upgrade to the 0.40% Premium plan, you’ll have unlimited access to a team of certified financial planners while retaining all of the benefits of the Digital Plan.
You also have the option to get matched with a pre-vetted CFP through Betterment. The fees vary but usually carry a minimum balance of $100,000.
What Do Your Management Fees Pay For?
The Vanguard Personal Advisor Service manages IRAs, Individual accounts (mutual fund or brokerage), Trusts, and Vanguard Variable Annuity accounts.
Accounts excluded from their advisory services (and don’t count toward the $50,000 minimum balance):
- 401(k) & 403(b) accounts
- i401(k) accounts
- 529 accounts
- UGMA/UTMA accounts
- Accounts held outside of Vanguard
Accounts excluded from Betterment are:
- 529 accounts
- Custodial accounts
- Solo 401(k)s
- Self-directed accounts (you can’t choose your own funds or stocks)
Depending on what your investment strategy is will determine what you choose.
Vanguard’s product offerings outnumber Betterment’s. In addition to Vanguard’s 3,000 no-transaction-fee mutual funds and 1,800 commission-free ETFs, you can choose between individual stocks, options, bonds, and CDs. They even have a trading platform (although mediocre in comparison to others like Fidelity).
Vanguard’s shortlist of product offerings:
- Traditional and Roth IRAs
- 529 College Savings plans
- SEP, i401k, and SIMPLE IRAs
- 403b services
- Individual and Joint accounts
- 401k Rollovers
- Mutual Funds & ETFs
- Individual Stocks, Bonds, CDs, and Options
- Factor-based Investing (smart beta)
- Sector Investing
- ESG (environmental, social, and governance) Investing
If DIY investing appeals to you, Vanguard might be a better fit. They have the edge over Betterment in this category.
However, if you’re looking for a more hands-off approach and prefer to invest with Betterment’s robo-advisor service, you’ll be in good hands.
With their guidance, you’ll construct a globally-diversified investment portfolio across 12 asset classes using pre-selected, low-cost ETFs (most notably Vanguard, Charles Schwab, and iShares).
It’s for this reason that DIYers might be turned off by Betterment’s pre-selected funds. You lose the ability to choose when taking a “hands-off” approach.
The flip side to this argument:
Betterment’s funds are already selected, so your work is done. All you have to do is create your investor profile and set your short and long-term financial goals in your Betterment account. They also use fractional shares, so you’re fully invested at all times.
You do have three additional portfolio options:
- Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) puts your money in companies meeting specific social, environmental, and governance criteria
- Goldman Sachs Smart Beta is a multi-factor modeled portfolio (as opposed to a traditional market-cap-weighting) looking to take an even greater calculated risk for potentially higher returns
- BlackRock Target Income is a 100% bond portfolio and lets you choose between short-term and long-term fixed-income securities
Betterment may not have as many investment options like Vanguard, but they make up for it under the hood.
Enhanced Suite of Automated Tools
It’s a beast of a service equipped with a Retirement Planning Suite, automatic rebalancing, tax-loss harvesting, goal-based investing, and tax-coordinated portfolios.
While Betterment offers automatic rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting 24/7, Vanguard’s rebalancing occurs quarterly, and tax-loss harvesting is on an “as needed” client-by-client basis.
General rule-of-thumb: the higher your tax bracket, the more you’ll benefit from tax-loss harvesting.
Here’s where the edge tilts to Betterment as Vanguard lacks the 24/7 automation, daily tax-loss harvesting and rebalancing capabilities Betterment provides.
A Target Date Fund Alternative to Betterment?
This is what matters most to all investors, especially the DIYers. You want your portfolio to remain optimized for taxes (so you’re not paying unnecessary costs to Uncle Sam), and you want to stay the course with your asset allocation (i.e., all portfolios drift outside of their target asset allocation and will need to be rebalanced).
If you’re not sold on Betterment’s options, the idea of paying even a 0.25% management fee makes you queasy and would like to do it yourself while remaining mostly hands-off, you have alternatives:
- Vanguard Target Date Retirement Funds
- Vanguard LifeStrategy Funds
Target Date Funds rebalance your portfolio automatically, so you’re still mostly hands-off. These funds start with a high stock-to-bond allocation then gradually shift away from stocks and add more bonds as you near retirement.
Vanguard puts it this way:
The funds’ managers gradually shift each fund’s asset allocation to fewer stocks and more bonds so the fund becomes more conservative the closer you get to retirement.
Ideal for the Lazy
Personal finance whiz Ramit Sethi is a big fan of these and even talks about them in his book, I Will Teach You To Be Rich:
“That’s why target-date funds are great: They’re designed to appeal to people who are lazy. In other words, for many people, the ease of use of these funds far outweighs any minor loss of returns that might occur…”
Or, if you prefer a static asset allocation, consider Vanguard’s LifeStrategy Funds. These are similar to target-date funds with one exception:
They rebalance to ensure your correct allocation stays the course as Mr. Bogle would say. For example, if you got their growth fund with an asset allocation of 80% stocks and 20% bonds, the fund manager would rebalance to maintain that stock-to-bond ratio.
Vanguard LifeStrategy Funds carry an average expense ratio of 0.13%.Tweet This
This approach does have its critics. Betterment argues that target-date funds are out of date for a few reasons:
- Lacks sophistication of tax coordinated portfolios
- Target date funds aren’t tailor-made to the individual
- Exact years are more efficient than a broad date
Betterment says you’ll earn a 1.48% greater return than the average investor because of their enhanced suite of automated tools and 24/7 portfolio monitoring. You’ll also potentially save 0.77% a year through tax-loss harvesting which offsets their 0.25% management fee.
There is no “one size fits all” approach when it comes to investing. Every person’s situation is different. It’s a good idea to know what’s available before making a decision.
Both Betterment and Vanguard possess a large pool of educational resources. Vanguard’s blog, Investment research and commentary, and Investor education explain everything you need to know to manage your portfolio effectively. Check out their tools and calculators or this page full of lessons.
You’ll find Betterment and Vanguard apps for both iOS and Android users. I’d tilt the digital experience in Betterment’s favor here. The ease of use and aesthetics found while navigating their site is superior.
Who’s better? I use both. I have a Big Purchase investing goal through Betterment, and I recently started using their Cash Reserve savings account.
My Roth and taxable brokerage accounts live at Vanguard. I’ve yet to have a bad experience with either company.
If you’re going the DIY route, use Vanguard to build a portfolio of low-cost index funds or ETFs and rebalance at least once a year. Be mindful of optimizing your portfolio for taxes and put the right assets in the right investment buckets.
If rebalancing once a year doesn’t sound like enough, try it twice a year or quarterly.
If you’re going the “hands-off” route, use Betterment and let them build a globally-diversified portfolio for you. Their features are exceptional and include a retirement planning suite, tax-coordinated portfolios, and daily automatic rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting. Their 0.25% management fee is pennies on the dollar in comparison to the competition.
What’s important is that you get started.